Wednesday | 21 Oct 2020
22 Nov 2018

Germany’s NetzDG

A key test for combatting online hate

William Echikson / Olivia Knodt

0
Download Publication

2912 Downloads

Germany’s Network Enforcement Act, or NetzDG law represents a key test for combatting hate speech on the internet. Under the law, which came into effect on January 1, 2018, online platforms face fines of up to €50 million for systemic failure to delete illegal content. Supporters see the legislation as a necessary and efficient response to the threat of online hatred and extremism. Critics view it as an attempt to privatise a new ‘draconian’ censorship regime, forcing social media platforms to respond to this new painful liability with unnecessary takedowns.

This study shows that the reality is in between these extremes. NetzDG has not provoked mass requests for takedowns. Nor has it forced internet platforms to adopt a ‘take down, ask later’ approach. At the same time, it remains uncertain whether NetzDG has achieved significant results in reaching its stated goal of preventing hate speech.

This paper begins by explaining the background that led to the development and passage of NetzDG. It examines the reaction to the law by civil society, platforms and the government. It concludes with suggestions, for platforms, civil society and the authorities, on ways to improve the law to be effective in the fight against online hate while keeping the internet open and free.

CEPS acknowledges the Counter Extremism Project’s support for this research. The study was conducted in complete independence. It is based on interviews with regulators, company representatives, and civil society activists. The authors take full responsibility for its findings.

Related Publications

Browse through the list of related publications.

How to Fully Reap the Benefits of the Internal Market for E-Commerce?

New economic opportunities and challenges for digital services 20 years after the adoption of the e-Commerce Directive Policy

Dinner for three

EU, China and the US around the geographical indications table

Public Procurement

How open is the European Union to US firms and beyond?

IoT 4 SDGs

What can the Digital Transformation and IoT achieve for Agenda 2030?

Artificial Intelligence and Cybersecurity

Task Force Evaluation of the HLEG Trustworthy AI Assessment List (Pilot Version)

Feasibility Study: Introducing “One-In-One-Out” in the European Commission

Final Report for the German Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy

DIGITISING AGRIFOOD

Pathways and Challenges