24 Jan 2019

Solidarity for Adamowicz, Poland, and Europe


Author: Danuta Hübner

Originally Published: Project Syndicate, 21 January 2019

As the birthplace of Solidarity, the movement that helped bring communism to an end in Europe, Gdansk has long served as a symbol of freedom and openness. But now the city is coping with the assassination on January 13 of its mayor, Pawel Adamowicz. Simply writing that sentence is a surreal and painful experience for me. The question is what consequences his public murder will have for Poland – and for Europe.

Adamowicz had been the subject of repeated political attacks in recent years. Because he was a tough leader with strong support in Gda?sk and beyond, his enemies pulled out all the stops to malign his reputation. But he was not alone. Since the Law and Justice (PiS) party came to power in 2015, European Council President Donald Tusk, judges such as Andrzej Rzepli?ski and Ma?gorzata Gersdorf, and even the charity founder Jerzy Owsiak have all been targeted with shameless smear campaigns by the state-run media.

Polish politics has reached a point where dehumanizing one’s opponents is the surest route to victory. In the case of the PiS, such adversaries include not just opposition parties, but also immigrants, independent judges, and average citizens protesting abuses of power. Tactics that were once used only by gutter tabloids have now gone mainstream.

Accordingly, opponents of the PiS are described as scumbags, parasites, germ carriers, communists, thieves, traitors, and more. Smear campaigns against judges, threats to curtail independent media, and anti-Semitic slanders have become the new normal in political discourse. One senior PiS official has gone so far as to call the EU flag a “dirty rag.” At Polish Independence Day marches, the European flag has been burned to chants of “Death to the Enemies of the Fatherland!”

Meanwhile, in Gda?sk and other cities, young nationalists have begun publishing fake “death certificates” of politicians such as Adamowicz. In Katowice, portraits of “unpatriotic” MEPs are hung from gallows. Citing “negligible social harm,” prosecutors do not bother to investigate these threats. Apparently, young neo-fascists should be allowed to sow their wild oats. In fact, the leading loudmouths of the far-right National Radical Camp (ONR) march with police protection. And while independent cultural institutions such as theaters and museums are shuttered, pro-Russian fundamentalist organizations are allowed to prosper.

It was in this hysterical, xenophobic political atmosphere that a recently released convict – most likely suffering from a mental disorder – ran onstage during a benefit concert for Owsiak’s charity and plunged a knife into Adamowicz’s heart. I, for one, refuse to believe that the killer’s actions had nothing to do with the hate-filled rhetoric to which he has been exposed since leaving prison. After all, on the day Adamowicz died, two alt-right weeklies featured covers essentially declaring war on Poland’s judiciary and the European Union.

Such messages must have a damaging effect on the psyches of disturbed and impressionable people like Adamowicz’s killer. A man who goes from the isolation of prison to a media environment saturated with incitements to violence is practically defenseless against propaganda. When he hears “death to the enemies of the Fatherland,” there is a good chance that he will take those words literally.

Those now mourning Adamowicz should not fool themselves into thinking his murder happened in a vacuum. Willful acts of collective amnesia and whispers to “keep quiet over this coffin” will not do. Now is the time to get angry and express our moral outrage over the direction of Polish politics and public life. All Poles who still believe in freedom and openness must make themselves heard loud and clear that we will not succumb to threats and blackmail from extremists, including those in the government.

In confronting today’s morbid, state-sponsored hysteria, Polish citizens have no choice but to stand in total opposition to the political status quo. They should do so not in shame, but with pride. Polish democracy is under attack and must be defended with the same vigor as that of those who seek to destroy it. We must defend liberal politicians, free media, independent judges, and activists such as W?adys?aw Frasyniuk, Klementyna Suchanow, and Pawe? Kasprzak – all of whom are now under sustained attack.

Hate speech and threats to liberal values are not confined to Poland. Across the EU, one in four voters now supports populist parties. And without bothering to ask for the public’s consent, Poland’s government has formed an “axis” with Italy’s likeminded government, in order to provide a populist “counterweight” to the governments committed to liberal democratic values. This unity among illiberal governments is part of a larger populist project aimed at capturing – and potentially destroying – the EU by prevailing in the European Parliament elections this May.

The commitment to liberal democratic values has long driven the European project forward. But a new axis of troublemakers now wants to derail it. To ensure that they do not succeed, Europeans must show the same courage and resolve as Adamowicz did throughout his career.

Danuta Hübner is Chair of the European Parliament’s Committee on Constitutional Affairs and a member of the CEPS board. She was Poland’s first European Commissioner and is a professor at the Warsaw School of Economics.

CEPS Commentaries offer concise, policy-oriented insights into topical issues in European affairs. As an institution, CEPS takes no official position on questions of EU policy. The views expressed are attributable only to the author and not to any institution with which they are associated.

© CEPS 2019