Tuesday | 20 Oct 2020
05 Dec 2019

Feasibility Study: Introducing “One-In-One-Out” in the European Commission

Final Report for the German Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy

Andrea Renda / Moritz Laurer / Ada Modzelewska / Antonella Zarra

0
Download Publication

813 Downloads

The need to consolidate and streamline the stock of legislation and reduce the unnecessary costs associated with legal rules has been increasingly felt by regulated stakeholders and governments in many developed and emerging economies. In many OECD countries, including many EU Member States and Canada, Korea, Mexico, the United States, this has led governments of various political orientations to introduce forms of regulatory budgeting, in which administrations are asked to identify, whenever new provisions introduce regulatory costs, existing provisions that could be repealed or revised, thereby offsetting the cost increase. In some countries these rules have implied a one-to-one offset, whereas in other countries the provisions imposed also a reduction, as in the case of UK’s one-in-two-out and one-in-three-out rules, and the US one-in-two-out rule. This is why we generically refer to these rules as “One-In-X-Out”, or OIXO.

Overall, national experiences with OIXO rules have led to positive results: hence, many EU member states have started to advocate the adoption of a similar strategy also at the EU level. Most recently, the new President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, announced that the institution will apply the “‘One-In, One-Out’ (OIOO) principle “to cut red tape”, making it now officially part of its better regulation agenda. However, its contours and modus operandi must still be defined. Based on the results of our analysis, we developed a proposed system, which would be likely to achieve the positive results observed in member states and other OECD countries, while at the same time mitigating or fully addressing the concerns expressed by the previous Commission.

Related Publications

Browse through the list of related publications.

How to Fully Reap the Benefits of the Internal Market for E-Commerce?

New economic opportunities and challenges for digital services 20 years after the adoption of the e-Commerce Directive Policy

Dinner for three

EU, China and the US around the geographical indications table

Public Procurement

How open is the European Union to US firms and beyond?

IoT 4 SDGs

What can the Digital Transformation and IoT achieve for Agenda 2030?

Artificial Intelligence and Cybersecurity

Task Force Evaluation of the HLEG Trustworthy AI Assessment List (Pilot Version)