This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
Array
(
[nid] => 3056
[type] => book
[language] =>
[uid] => 31
[status] => 1
[created] => 1270553452
[changed] => 1270553519
[comment] => 0
[promote] => 0
[moderate] => 0
[sticky] => 0
[tnid] => 0
[translate] => 0
[vid] => 3056
[revision_uid] => 31
[title] => On High Stakes, Stakeholders and Bulgaria’s EU Membership
[body] =>
€ 0.00
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
[log] =>
[revision_timestamp] => 1270553519
[format] => 1
[name] => anne.harrington...
[picture] =>
[data] => a:6:{s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:24:"xmlsitemap_user_priority";s:2:"-2";s:8:"file_add";a:0:{}s:5:"block";a:1:{s:5:"block";a:1:{i:4;i:1;}}s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-9e1b1283add12c57fc7c08c01edbe6a6";s:5:"piwik";a:1:{s:16:"piwik_token_auth";s:9:"anonymous";}}
[model] => 978-92-9079-987-0
[list_price] => 0.00000
[cost] => 0.00000
[sell_price] => 0.00000
[weight] => 0
[weight_units] => g
[length] => 0
[width] => 0
[height] => 0
[length_units] => cm
[pkg_qty] => 1
[default_qty] => 1
[unique_hash] => 54bb5869505c72f5eaf5072b4af6ac7e
[ordering] => 0
[shippable] => 1
[path] => book/high-stakes-stakeholders-and-bulgaria’s-eu-membership
[field_book_isbn] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 978-92-9079-987-0
[safe] => 978-92-9079-987-0
)
)
[field_book_number] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 27
[safe] => 27
[view] => 27
)
)
[field_book_short_title] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
)
[field_book_author_external] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => Antoinette Primatarova
[safe] => Antoinette Primatarova
)
)
[field_book_old_path] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] =>
[safe] =>
)
)
[field_book_pages] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 20
[view] => 20
)
)
[field_book_publication_date] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 2010-04-06T00:00:00
[timezone] => Europe/Brussels
[timezone_db] => Europe/Brussels
[date_type] => date
[view] =>
06 April 2010
)
)
[field_book_author] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[nid] =>
[safe] => Array
(
)
[view] =>
)
)
[field_image_cache] => Array
(
[0] =>
)
[field_type] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => PDF
[format] =>
[safe] =>
PDF
[view] => PDF file
)
[1] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
[2] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
)
[print_display] => 1
[print_display_comment] => 0
[print_display_urllist] => 1
[signup] => 0
[tags] => Array
(
)
[uc_order_product_id] =>
[last_comment_timestamp] => 1270553452
[last_comment_name] =>
[comment_count] => 0
[taxonomy] => Array
(
[taxonomy_term_22] => Array
(
[title] => Politics and Institutions
[href] => taxonomy/term/22
[attributes] => Array
(
[rel] => tag
[title] =>
)
)
[taxonomy_term_94] => Array
(
[title] => EPIN Working Papers
[href] => catalog/94
[attributes] => Array
(
[rel] => tag
[title] => This series contains analysis of key issues raised by the debate on the future of Europe and produced by the European Policy Institutes Network, a network of dynamic think tanks and policy institutes focusing on current EU political and policy debates.
)
)
)
[files] => Array
(
[2566] => stdClass Object
(
[fid] => 2566
[uid] => 31
[filename] => EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[filepath] => files/book/2010/04/EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[filemime] => application/pdf
[filesize] => 289117
[status] => 1
[timestamp] => 2010-04-06 13:30:52
[nid] => 3056
[vid] => 3056
[description] => EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[list] => 1
[weight] => 0
)
)
[flatrate] => Array
(
)
[shipping_type] => small_package
[shipping_address] => stdClass Object
(
[first_name] =>
[last_name] =>
[company] => CEPS
[street1] => place du Congres 1
[street2] =>
[city] => Brussels
[zone] => 94
[postal_code] => 1000
[country] => 56
[phone] =>
)
[usps] => Array
(
[vid] => 3056
[nid] => 3056
[container] => RECTANGULAR
)
[weightquote] => Array
(
)
[build_mode] => 0
[readmore] => 1
[content] =>
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
[attributes] => Array
(
)
[links] =>
[template_files] => Array
(
[0] => node-product
[1] => node-book
)
[node] => stdClass Object
(
[nid] => 3056
[type] => book
[language] =>
[uid] => 31
[status] => 1
[created] => 1270553452
[changed] => 1270553519
[comment] => 0
[promote] => 0
[moderate] => 0
[sticky] => 0
[tnid] => 0
[translate] => 0
[vid] => 3056
[revision_uid] => 31
[title] => On High Stakes, Stakeholders and Bulgaria’s EU Membership
[body] =>
€ 0.00
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
[log] =>
[revision_timestamp] => 1270553519
[format] => 1
[name] => anne.harrington@ceps.eu
[picture] =>
[data] => a:6:{s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:24:"xmlsitemap_user_priority";s:2:"-2";s:8:"file_add";a:0:{}s:5:"block";a:1:{s:5:"block";a:1:{i:4;i:1;}}s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-9e1b1283add12c57fc7c08c01edbe6a6";s:5:"piwik";a:1:{s:16:"piwik_token_auth";s:9:"anonymous";}}
[model] => 978-92-9079-987-0
[list_price] => 0.00000
[cost] => 0.00000
[sell_price] => 0.00000
[weight] => 0
[weight_units] => g
[length] => 0
[width] => 0
[height] => 0
[length_units] => cm
[pkg_qty] => 1
[default_qty] => 1
[unique_hash] => 54bb5869505c72f5eaf5072b4af6ac7e
[ordering] => 0
[shippable] => 1
[path] => book/high-stakes-stakeholders-and-bulgaria’s-eu-membership
[field_book_isbn] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 978-92-9079-987-0
[safe] => 978-92-9079-987-0
)
)
[field_book_number] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 27
[safe] => 27
[view] => 27
)
)
[field_book_short_title] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
)
[field_book_author_external] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => Antoinette Primatarova
[safe] => Antoinette Primatarova
)
)
[field_book_old_path] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] =>
[safe] =>
)
)
[field_book_pages] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 20
[view] => 20
)
)
[field_book_publication_date] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => 2010-04-06T00:00:00
[timezone] => Europe/Brussels
[timezone_db] => Europe/Brussels
[date_type] => date
[view] =>
06 April 2010
)
)
[field_book_author] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[nid] =>
[safe] => Array
(
)
[view] =>
)
)
[field_image_cache] => Array
(
[0] =>
)
[field_type] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[value] => PDF
[format] =>
[safe] =>
PDF
[view] => PDF file
)
[1] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
[2] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[view] =>
)
)
[print_display] => 1
[print_display_comment] => 0
[print_display_urllist] => 1
[signup] => 0
[tags] => Array
(
)
[uc_order_product_id] =>
[last_comment_timestamp] => 1270553452
[last_comment_name] =>
[comment_count] => 0
[taxonomy] => Array
(
[22] => stdClass Object
(
[tid] => 22
[vid] => 3
[name] => Politics and Institutions
[description] =>
[weight] => 8
)
[94] => stdClass Object
(
[tid] => 94
[vid] => 4
[name] => EPIN Working Papers
[description] => This series contains analysis of key issues raised by the debate on the future of Europe and produced by the European Policy Institutes Network, a network of dynamic think tanks and policy institutes focusing on current EU political and policy debates.
[weight] => 0
)
)
[files] => Array
(
[2566] => stdClass Object
(
[fid] => 2566
[uid] => 31
[filename] => EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[filepath] => files/book/2010/04/EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[filemime] => application/pdf
[filesize] => 289117
[status] => 1
[timestamp] => 2010-04-06 13:30:52
[nid] => 3056
[vid] => 3056
[description] => EPIN WP27 Primatorova.pdf
[list] => 1
[weight] => 0
)
)
[flatrate] => Array
(
)
[shipping_type] => small_package
[shipping_address] => stdClass Object
(
[first_name] =>
[last_name] =>
[company] => CEPS
[street1] => place du Congres 1
[street2] =>
[city] => Brussels
[zone] => 94
[postal_code] => 1000
[country] => 56
[phone] =>
)
[usps] => Array
(
[vid] => 3056
[nid] => 3056
[container] => RECTANGULAR
)
[weightquote] => Array
(
)
[build_mode] => 0
[readmore] => 1
[content] => Array
(
[print_links] => Array
(
[#weight] => -101
[#suffix] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[display_price] => Array
(
[#weight] => -10
[#access] => 1
[#value] => € 0.00
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[field_book_short_title] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_book_short_title
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => -4
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_book_short_title
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => text_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] =>
[safe] =>
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_book_short_title
[#title] => Short title
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[field_book_author] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_book_author
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => -3
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_book_author
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => nodereference_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[nid] =>
[safe] => Array
(
)
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_book_author
[#title] => CEPS Authors
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[field_book_publication_date] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_book_publication_date
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => -1
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_book_publication_date
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => date_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] => 2010-04-06T00:00:00
[timezone] => Europe/Brussels
[timezone_db] => Europe/Brussels
[date_type] => date
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
[#children] => 06 April 2010
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] => 06 April 2010
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_book_publication_date
[#title] => Date of publication
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#children] => 06 April 2010
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] =>
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
[#printed] => 1
)
[model] => Array
(
[#value] => SKU: 978-92-9079-987-0
[#access] => 0
[#weight] => 0
)
[#pre_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_alter_extra_weights
)
[#content_extra_fields] => Array
(
[title] => Array
(
[label] => Title
[description] => Node module form.
[weight] => -5
)
[body_field] => Array
(
[label] => Description
[description] => Node module form.
[weight] => 9
)
[revision_information] => Array
(
[label] => Revision information
[description] => Node module form.
[weight] => 19
)
[author] => Array
(
[label] => Authoring information
[description] => Node module form.
[weight] => 20
)
[options] => Array
(
[label] => Publishing options
[description] => Node module form.
[weight] => 25
)
[comment_settings] => Array
(
[label] => Comment settings
[description] => Comment module form.
[weight] => 20
)
[menu] => Array
(
[label] => Menu settings
[description] => Menu module form.
[weight] => 18
)
[taxonomy] => Array
(
[label] => Taxonomy
[description] => Taxonomy module form.
[weight] => 5
)
[path] => Array
(
[label] => Path settings
[description] => Path module form.
[weight] => 21
)
[attachments] => Array
(
[label] => File attachments
[description] => Upload module form.
[weight] => 6
[view] => files
)
[print] => Array
(
[label] => Printer, e-mail and PDF versions
[description] => Print module form.
[weight] => 17
)
[shipping] => Array
(
[label] => Shipping
[description] => Shipping settings form.
[weight] => 8
)
[base] => Array
(
[label] => Product information
[description] => Product module form.
[weight] => 7
)
[body] => Array
(
[label] => Description
[description] => Node description. (View tab)
[weight] => 10
)
)
[field_type] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_type
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => 2
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_type
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => text_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] => PDF
[format] =>
[safe] => PDF
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
[#children] => PDF file
)
[1] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_type
[#weight] => 1
[#theme] => text_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[#delta] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
)
[2] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_type
[#weight] => 2
[#theme] => text_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] =>
[format] =>
[safe] =>
[#delta] => 2
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] => PDF file
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_type
[#title] => type
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#children] => PDF file
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[list_price] => Array
(
[#value] => List Price: € 0.00
[#access] => 0
[#weight] => 2
)
[cost] => Array
(
[#value] => Cost: € 0.00
[#access] =>
[#weight] => 3
)
[field_book_number] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_book_number
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => 3
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_book_number
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => text_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] => 27
[safe] => 27
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
[#children] => 27
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] => 27
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_book_number
[#title] => Number
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#children] => 27
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[field_book_pages] => Array
(
[#type_name] => book
[#context] => full
[#field_name] => field_book_pages
[#post_render] => Array
(
[0] => content_field_wrapper_post_render
)
[#weight] => 4
[field] => Array
(
[#description] =>
[items] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[#formatter] => default
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type_name] => book
[#field_name] => field_book_pages
[#weight] => 0
[#theme] => number_formatter_default
[#item] => Array
(
[value] => 20
[#delta] => 0
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#theme_used] => 1
[#printed] => 1
[#type] =>
[#value] =>
[#prefix] =>
[#suffix] =>
[#children] => 20
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] => 20
[#printed] => 1
)
[#single] => 1
[#attributes] => Array
(
)
[#required] =>
[#parents] => Array
(
)
[#tree] =>
[#context] => full
[#page] => 1
[#field_name] => field_book_pages
[#title] => Pages
[#access] => 1
[#label_display] => inline
[#teaser] =>
[#node] => stdClass Object
*RECURSION*
[#type] => content_field
[#children] => 20
[#printed] => 1
)
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#children] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[sell_price] => Array
(
[#value] => Price: € 0.00
[#access] => 0
[#weight] => 4
)
[weight] => Array
(
[#value] => Weight: 0 g
[#access] => 0
[#weight] => 5
)
[files] => Array
(
[#weight] => 6
[#value] =>
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[dimensions] => Array
(
[#value] => Dimensions: 0 cm × 0 cm × 0 cm
[#access] => 0
[#weight] => 6
)
[add_to_cart] => Array
(
[#weight] => 10
[#access] => 1
[#value] =>
[#title] =>
[#description] =>
[#printed] => 1
)
[body] => Array
(
[#weight] => 10
[#value] => This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
€ 0.00
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
This paper argues against the view that Bulgaria’s EU accession was premature and that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism (CVM) is not delivering. The EU’s continued leverage and the efficacy of the CVM are explained in a framework that goes beyond the dual-conditionality paradigm of incentives and sanctions, and beyond the unitary players model of EU-Bulgarian relations. In this framework, the CVM is viewed as an instrument for supportive reinforcement rather than for the imposition of sanctions. Furthermore, it is seen as targeting not just the government, but all Bulgarian stakeholders. The CVM is regarded as very effective at the level of public opinion and civil society, and as a mechanism that contributes to ‘sandwiching’ reform-reluctant Bulgarian governments between pressure from Brussels and domestic pressure for reforms. The CVM is also deemed useful for Bulgaria’s further Europeanisation beyond the narrower pre-accession phase of ‘EU-isation’. The paper suggests that eventual post-accession benchmarks might be appropriate in the process of further EU enlargement if properly understood as instruments for granting support and if discussed broadly with stakeholders beyond the executive. Concerning the efficiency/legitimacy dilemma, it is asserted that the CVM is an opportunity for increasing the EU’s legitimacy.
Antoinette Primatarova is a Programme Director at the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia.
Date of publication:
06 April 2010
[field_type_rendered] =>
[field_book_number_rendered] =>
[field_book_pages_rendered] =>
[unpublished] =>
[classes] => node node-type-book
[authors] => By Antoinette Primatarova
)
